A first-timer's account of the
International Photographic Competition
By Penn Hansa, PPA Intern
I naïvely thought I had been at PPA long enough to know
what to expect when we went to the International Photographic Competition -
lots of images, seasoned judges sitting in a dim room deciding whether the
image presented should merit and a solemn air of importance surrounding the
I was only half correct. IPC is much, much more.
It's an invaluable experience, a chance to learn from
some of the most talented photographers in the industry and oddly enough, it feels
like a family reunion -- if your family were made up of experienced IPC judges,
"Do you want to see my granddaughter?" a judge asks,
while waiting for the next round of judging to start. He pulls out his iPhone
and flicks through the images before anyone replies.
"Only if I get to show you mine," another judge replies.
"And then we can judge the images!" They all laugh.
But when the session starts, it's all business. In the
digital room, the judges sit in twos or threes, and as an image comes on the
screen in front of them, they'll review and tap in their vote on an iPod Touch.
Oftentimes, they'll lean closer to the screen to see the image more closely,
viewing it from different angles to make sure they haven't missed a pixel when
A common misconception about IPC is that the judges will
favor images that suit their style. Because they score in a matter of seconds,
it seems easy to believe it. But when a judge challenges an image, it's all
laid out on the table and it's clear to see that their deliberation is intense.
They'll each speak at length about why they favor an image to merit or what
fell short, citing the 12 elements
of a merit image.
"It's not about the treatment of an image, and whether I
like it or not," said Allison Watkins, M.Photog.Cr., CPP. "I have to put my
preferences aside to see the image impartially."
I wanted to see more of the thought process behind the
deliberation, so I headed to the critique rooms, where judges offer their
thoughts and constructive criticism about the image. For each image that is
being critiqued, the judge will talk about the image as a whole, explaining
their stream of thought as they look at it, including both the positive and the
negative. It's a real learning experience to see exactly what makes an image
merit and truly invaluable.
I settled behind Gregg Wurtzler, M.Photog.Cr., as he
critiqued a few images, and then pulled up a new one. Wurtzler has 14 years of
judging and critiquing images under his belt.
"What do you think about this one?" he asked me as he
made his initial assessment.
I tried to keep in mind what I had learned about the 12
elements from watching earlier judging and critiques, but was drawing a blank.
I liked the image, but something about it seemed off, and I couldn't place my
finger on the correct term.
He just chuckled at my confusion and started his
critique, first complimenting the photographer on his choice of subject and
capturing the right moment, then describing how the photographer could have
improved his composition, to notice the placing of the subject's hands and the
busy background that was detracting from him.
"At first, it's sometimes difficult to look at the image
and have to guess why the judges didn't merit it," Wurtzler said after he
finished the critique. "But we've all been doing this long enough that we can
usually pinpoint what it is."
Later, I sat behind Mark Garber, M.Photog.Cr., CPP, who
has helped thousands of photographers with his critiques.
For any photographer who hasn't entered competitions,
take this as an incentive: Garber is a huge advocate, and made a point to
encourage all the photographers in his critiques to keep entering their images.
"Competition is quickest way to improve photographic
skills," he said. "Every photographer has had images that didn't merit, so
don't be discouraged when it happens to you."
Convinced of the fun and invaluable experience IPC is
yet? Find out more about entering your images, becoming a PPA-approved juror
and other competitions at PPA.com/IPC.